Setting the stage for fireworks, Democrats in each house of the Legislature
passed separate bills Thursday to guarantee medical care for millions of
uninsured Californians.
"We now have a target for people to shoot at," Senate President Pro Tem Don
Perata said at a news conference shortly after passage of his Senate Bill 48 and
of Assembly Bill 8.
Backers hailed the measures as critical to improving the quality of life for
uninsured Californians ranging from low-wage workers to single parents to
children who entered the state illegally.
"We're going to say, to all Californians, from this point forward, that
health care is a right afforded to everyone in this state," Assembly Speaker
Fabian Núñez said.
Hundreds of bills were acted upon this week by Assembly and Senate members,
who adjourned Thursday, a day before the deadline for deciding measures proposed
in their legislative house.
Republicans lambasted the Democratic health care bills as the largest "tax
increase" in state history, totaling more than $5 billion.
Steve Maviglio, Núñez's spokesman, countered that the measures call for a
fee, not a tax, an important legal distinction.
Assemblyman Sam Blakeslee, R-San Luis Obispo, characterized the Democratic
proposals as wrong-way leadership.
"We'll take a step backward," he said.
The two health care bills, opposed by the GOP, passed on votes of 47-32 for
Núñez's bill, AB 8, and 23-16 on Perata's proposal, SB 48.
The two Democratic leaders characterized their proposals as very similar.
Thursday's action sets the stage for negotiations that will involve hospital,
doctor, nurse, business, insurance, consumer, labor union and low-income
advocacy groups that are among the Capitol's most powerful players.
Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger, through a spokeswoman, applauded Thursday's votes
but said "this is just a starting point for negotiations -- everything's on the
table."
"The governor has said all along that he doesn't care who gets credit as long
as we fix our broken health care system," spokeswoman Sabrina Lockhart said.
Núñez, Perata and Schwarzenegger are all committed to insuring most or all of
the 6.5 million people who lack health insurance at some point during the year.
Nearly 5 million lack coverage consistently.
Much of the fight is over who should pay -- and how much.
Núñez, Perata and Schwarzenegger basically agree on requiring employers to
help foot the bill, creating a state-run insurance pool, mandating that
insurance companies cover anyone who applies, and forcing insurers to spend a
larger share of premiums on medical care.
The two Democratic bills propose a "pay-or-play" system that would require
employers to spend 7.5 percent of their payroll on health care or pay into a
state fund that would provide comprehensive coverage.
Workers served by the state pool would pay some of the insurance premium --
Perata's bill limits such costs to 5 percent of income, while Núñez's measure
does not specify a cap.
Núñez's plan, unlike Perata's, would exempt from the employer mandate
businesses that have been operating for three years or less, employ fewer than
two people, or have an annual payroll of less than $100,000.
Under SB 48, working Californians and their dependents with family incomes
above 400 percent of the federal poverty level -- about $62,000 for a family of
three -- would be required to have a minimum health coverage policy.
Núñez's proposal, AB 8, does not mandate that families earning more than a
certain amount obtain health insurance. Low-income families earning below 300
percent of the federal poverty level -- about $50,000 for a family of three --
would be eligible for subsidized coverage.
GOP proposals, killed in legislative committees, relied more on market
incentives and less on government intervention.
"We both want better (care) for all Californians," said Assemblyman John
Benoit, R-Palm Desert. "But we don't always feel that bigger government is the
way to get there."
Opponents of the Democratic bills claim that charging employers a mandatory
fee could drive businesses out of California while doing nothing to stem soaring
health care costs.
"Employer mandates threaten jobs and slow economic growth," the California
Chamber of Commerce said in a letter to lawmakers this month.
Assemblyman Todd Spitzer, R-Orange, said the 7.5 percent assessment on
businesses is an illegal mandate under federal law and could be overturned if
challenged in court.
Anthony Wright, director of Health Access California, a statewide health care
consumer advocacy coalition, applauded Thursday's votes.
"But more needs to be done to guarantee that coverage will be affordable for
consumers," he said.
Schwarzenegger has favored a broader sharing of the financial pain. The GOP
governor's plan, unlike those of Núñez and Perata, would require every
Californian to have at least a bare-bones insurance policy to protect against
catastrophic illness or injury. Premiums for subsidized coverage would be based
on family size and income.
Schwarzenegger would assess a 4 percent payroll charge on employers with at
least 10 workers if they do not provide health insurance. His plan also calls
for a 2 percent charge on doctors and a 4 percent fee on hospitals.
Schwarzenegger's plan would ensure health coverage for everyone, while each
Democratic plan would cover about 70 percent of the uninsured.
All three are counting on leveraging federal funds with state money to expand
public health programs.
Two other key measures cleared legislative hurdles.
Assembly Bill 1554, by Assemblyman Dave Jones, D-Sacramento, would require
health plans and health insurers to submit proposed rate increases for annual
approval.
The Assembly passed the bill Thursday, 43-33.
Senate Bill 840, by Sen. Sheila Kuehl, D-Santa Monica, would replace private
medical insurance with a state-run system to guarantee care for every resident.
The Senate passed the bill Wednesday, 23-15.
This article is protected by copyright and should not be printed or
distributed for anything except personal use.
The Sacramento Bee, 2100 Q St.,
P.O. Box 15779, Sacramento, CA 95852
Phone: (916) 321-1000